150 bucks for a real Merlin sound
 

How about everyone donates a few dollars and we buy 1c this real Merlin sound?

http://www.pole.se/sounds.asp

http://youtu.be/vCW-DMNcZeg

:grin:

Do we need another thread moaning about the sound?

http://forum.1cpublishing.eu/search....archid=1697611

:roll:

Only if we also get the real 109 whizzling sound ...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0cLmB...eature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nj4V8P3TLh4

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=50JXK...eature=related

i do have real engine sounds :cool:

OP and smink1701, you are one and the same person, aren't you?
Man, I'm getting so sick of it....brb making a virus, infecting those f**rs and making their engines sound like people throwing up, un-deleteable. Seriously.

wtf are you smokin dude:confused::confused::confused:

this thread is:
a) belittling towards the devs
b) just another spam to get his agenda forward
c) idiotic anyway
d) again cluttering up forums

Yes, I'm angry at his, as of now.

Dude, its only a request to help improve the game experience... sounds are just as important as anything else....

whats wrong with making a good game even better by listening to what the consumers want? its this kind of dedication that keeps a game going on for years

the way i see it you post goes like this

a) someone want to help your game get better.. how is that belittering? i call that dedicated for the greater good of the game series
b) many are not happy with the current sounds... its allways room for improvement
c)...... nothing wrong with cooler/more real sounds
d) how is your post helping?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeT2r...layer_embedded

someone is working on it.Hope we can use these mods online without worrying about VAC

Not sure what your point is but posting dead links isn't helpful

Awesome vid... sounds like a "Must Have"

It was not my intention to post a dead link. It was a link to a search containing all the threads about sounds in game. I was unaware this link would not work.

Anyway a dead link would be more useful than a thread linking to a sound download intended to help.

The way it should have sounded from the start... Battle of Britain, Rolls Royce and Daimler engines, Spitfires/109's...

They have known of the sound issues since the orginal IL-2.

Absolutely brilliant work. Will be looking out for this mod for sure!

Doesn't sound right for BoB at all. Wrong mark of engine with a totally different supercharger driving a very different propeller. ;)

For all those fanbois out there who are offended by people asking for something better than patchetic, here's the deal:

The devs could prevent all theese threads by posting an official statement:

"yes, these are placeholders, and we'll implement the final sounds in ....weeks"

or:

"don't hold your breath, it's gonna stay like this"

as simple as that, no need to be offended. All we want is to make this sim better.

I hope you are joking.

I agree

cont
 

Just download all the original sounds uploaded at CFS2 add on section at simouthouse ,they are all original sound recordings ,there since years.

how about they fix them on their own now that they have my money x2 and everyone elses?
Implement a dlc system like RoF. Ill buy it all. But I'm not donating them anything.

So I hope he's joking too heh

Wow, what a difference!
I'd love to have these sounds instead of the default ones.

The other side of the coin is not acting like a spoilt brat. Add your stupid suggestion to one of the already numerous threads regarding sound issues that DEVs download a simple sample, likely wrong, and use that. How helpful you are trying to be.

The childish demands that the DEV team do this and do that are tiresome.

Yes it would be nice to have better sounds, in fact better everything.. but post like yours wont help and are simply retarded.

Likely wrong, you mean as in the samples already used. Oh yeah right. Shouldn't be a problem then.

If you don't like the threads in this forum then go find a new one. You sound like my damn girlfriend. Jesus christ.

I merely pointed out that I paid a bucketload of money on this sim - not the cheapest one - and I got these incredibly crappy sounds. Does that really make me spoiled and childish? pff...

I don't understand you guys...

a: you're deaf
b: you think that getting real sounds would be worse (see a)
c: you think that negative criticism will make the devs commit sepuku
d: you are paid by 1c to humiliate everyone who points out something that needs to be fixed

I am hopeful that in due time they will come. There are bigger fish to fry at the moment. But if sounds is all you have to complain about then everything else must meet your expectation at this point. Hang on I am sure it will come.

Personally, I think the future of sounds in CloD will be the SDK and people like Jafa or Tiger33 (who was behind the great vid in this thread). MG had 10 years of supporting the original IL-2 and they never showed much interest in upgrading the lousy sounds in that game in all that time. I simply feel that sounds haven't ever been a priority at MG. I also feel that the unwillingness of MG to deal with this issue in the original game was one of the factors that led to the creation of the modding community for that game to the extent that it is today. I definitely agree that some official word on the future of sounds in CloD (either SDK sound mod accessibility or some official update with new sounds) would help reduce the number of threads about this topic.

Cheers,

Fafnir_6

Those recorded sounds aren't perfect, they lack dynamics sounds from behind/front/blade edge the same.
Instead of asking for the "perfect" (since decades the ms flight simulator way of doing it) i would ask for more procedural sound development.
But in first place, i think that people talking about shame/lame/crappy, have shame/lame/crappy education.

You can't make everyone happy with any one sound fix. That's why I think the user should be able to pick which sound mod/stock setup best reflects their auditory wishes in game. SDK is the future...

Fafnir_6

Speak for yourself, I've seen spits/109s in person and the game doesn't even remotely sound the same.

Fafnir_6

The best sound i heard in racing sims came from real recordings, but still isn't perfect, recorded sounds gaves you some amazing immersion but gets totally downed on certain situations, still everyone should be pleased in the future when options via mods will came.

yeah i dont need rev gauge

Jog on Mr 119 posts since you bought this game in april, Refelcted is a well respected member of the flight sim community and has been around the FS scene for quite some time, further more I for one value his opinion even if might be negative of sorts.
So i think you should back down and stop thinking that you have the right to be rude to people because you disagree with them.

That's my take on things too. I would definitely like improved sounds but not at the cost of losing their dynamic nature, it's a great deal of help if you fly with CEM and temp effects enabled. I can tune my engine by ear and look at the target, instead of burying my head in the cockpit gauges in the middle of the dogfight.

That goes doubly so for the Luftwaffe aircraft with their manual pitch props, i wouldn't use a canned/looping sample over dynamic sounds even if they sounded better.

Everything comes in time. I am sure there are going to be a handful of sound mods for the game. I think people are trying to add suggestions and help the devs. Not everyone is a technical sound expert for gaming. So we should not berate them for posting a suggestion to make the game better. I did read somewhere that the devs stated they are aware the sounds are not finished. It can not hurt to be productive and give examples of the sounds people would like to hear. After all it can give the devs additional ideas to improving the sounds in the game since many are only placeholders. Lets all support the game and the devs here!!!!

Have devs stated that the sounds are final?
At least I thought the outside sounds were placeholders, or didn't Oleg say we would get movie quality some time ago?

Don't forget, you're hearing the engines from inside a tin can, while wearing ear muffs. It wouldn't be terribly realistic for it to sound like a fly-by. Low=pass filter those tracks and see what they sound like, and you should have a reasonable approximation of what the planes will sound like with hearing protection. Or you can listen to the tracks while wearing shooting earplugs. Similar thing.