6.5 average seems about right.

No official dynamic campaigns, AI pilots stink. Why can't we get AI pilots on the level of 1946 with the 4.11 patch? Graphics are awesome, damage model is cool, except collisions seem off. My score 6. Give me some AI pilots that aren't blind and a dynamic campaign on the level of Lowengrin's, new score 10. Online is the only place the game is enjoyable because online is the only place I get shot down. I find myself loading up 1946 to get a challenge offline(but then I start missing the pretty graphics of CLoD),please 1C give me the best of both one day soon!

8 from me,I was really impressed at what had been fixed at the last update,the F/M's especially,no more grass in the hangars,no more weird colours in the cockpits,the clouds are back,the shadows look great,yeah it's starting to look good...........finally:)

Except a too slow 109 and gunsite that's lit by a 1 million candle power lamp.

Broken AI, other bugs, stopped me from giving it higher than 7

.

I'm sorry I just can't give it more than a 1 and that's only because there is no Zero. This game has been a nightmare since it's release and false promises.

wow that really got me thinking...imagine....they could have spent time making more planes flyable or even more planes and other models...i mean i was looking to play for england the other night and was STUNNED and disappointed that i was limited to basically spitfire and hurricane and Blenheim..i never gave that much thought before was always trying German side but when i found only three planes playable for the british i almost didnt believe it, i double checked and triple checked (i checked again just now)


anyways with that said i give it an 8 much of that has to do with the fact that the devs did their part and making the game playable, which the effort in and of it self is worthy of praise the fact that they did deliver is meaningful and should not go unnoticed. but the game is cool and if they can improve on this in the coming releases which they will we will have a fantastic final product...the one thing we do have control over however that is key to the success of the game is to not alienate the devs especially when they deliver or at least make a meaningful effort at doing so...

honestly who is giving 10's and 9's to CloD i can understand who gave a 8's based on online gaming and having fun, but 9's and 10's doesn't you think is way too much???

Just wondering...
who gave those numbers be welcome to say why that rating.

Potz

6/10 for me. Playing off line there's very little content, it's a bit of a desert to be fair, on the other hand I recognise that CloD's got a lot of depth at its core and is quite enjoyable just as a aircraft study sim. Nice.

With Il2 Clod, in my opinion, I have 3 """problems""":

- I Know that I purchased one simulator in beta state. (+one year ago)
- I have patience
- I try to be objetive

I'm a player of Il2 1946. I play in full real servers without engine management, with trees lie or with invisible and real trees, doing with my aircraft impossible maneuvers in the reality. I dont know if my Bf109 in Il2 1946 flight like reality, without worrying about the oil pressure, water temperature, the propeller pitch, the RPM or any plane management.
About IA...for me is the same, easy IA in Il2 1946 and Il2 Clod, in veteran mode or ace mode or easy mode....(Remember, >for me<)

About RoF...I have only 2 A/C. If I want more planes, $$$..pay
About DCS Black Shark...I have only one helo!! and very very complicate to play. Do you want planes? (like A10)...$$$$..pay

And in either case, in this simulators I have only one map.

Not my intention to compare this simulator with RoF or Black Shark o Il2 1946, only I try to say that we don't have a perfect simulator in any case, and I think that Il2 Clod is the first step to have a excelent sequel about WWII air combats...and...Is it possible one tank combat? Will be possible AAA position? or take my jeep and go from Calais till other city?

For me Il2 1946 isn't a 10 simulator...For me Il2 1946 isn't a real simulator, is one arcade/simulator.
If I wanted a simulator as real as many people want ... I would become a real pilot and not a PC player

remember, is only my opinion...and sry for my English ;) (And I know that the community with all comments about problems, is the best tool to improve the simulator)